When I first saw this type of carrier I thought they were a bit ridiculous, I had a leash mounted carrier, this item proved me wrong. While the leash mounted tab/ carrier is handy for quick easy access, short walks with my personal dog or being within a quarter mile of a disposable bin, the leash tab has major drawbacks compared to the pack out bag of not being secure swinging around and not being totally hygienic. I mounted the pack out bag to my hip pack, I found it to be comfortable and low profile enough to always be on me, it does not look like a "poop bag carrier" and I am ok with wearing it out in public. Where this product shines is walks over a half mile or when I am walking two to three medium to large sized dogs with smaller poops. This pouch may get a bit tight for poops from an 80lb+ dog, but I have successfully used it with an 80lb "happy hippo".